The Coaster Critic's Blog

The Coaster Critic's Blog
Popular Posts
    • Afterburn @ Carowinds | Roller Coaster Reviews
    • Thirteen Announced as Alton Towers' 2010 Psychoaster
    • Kentucky Kingdom's Chang Is Being Removed
    • Coolest 2010 Roller Coasters May Not Be in the U.S.
    • Big Bad Wolf: A Legend Reaches Its Expiration Date
    • Superman Ride of Steel Goes Bizarro at Six Flags New England
Featured Video
The Countdown is Over!
Presenting The Roller Coaster Wiki
Roller Coaster Wiki
Subscribe
Want it delivered? Subscribe to the RSS feed and my latest posts immediately.

Subscribe Via Email
Subscribe Via RSS
About
The Coaster Critic's Blog is your source for opinionated roller coaster reviews, theme park reviews and a coaster enthusiast's take on all the latest theme park news. Read more...
Social Sites
Facebook  Flickr  Last.fm  MySpace  Technorati  Twitter  YouTube  
Become a Fan!
The Coaster Critic on Facebook
In the News…
Featured on FOX Charlotte

Quoted by the New York Times



2 Comments

  1. #1 Anonymous says:
    September 19th, 2007 at 2:37 pm

    5 Questions:
    5)Why is Expedition GeForce the only foregin coaster on both lists?
    4)Why is Top Thrill Dragster on the list, and not the Kingda ka?
    3) Why is that one trick pony doing on the list:
    2) Why isn’t Stormrunner on the list?
    1)Why is Montu on the list, and not Alpengeist?

    Reply
  2. #2 The Coaster Critic says:
    September 19th, 2007 at 6:20 pm

    Good questions. The GTA’s are essentially a popularity contest. Even though they take votes from international enthusiasts, there’s going to be an American bias. With this sample of Amusement Today readers it’s no surprise that American parks & coasters dominate the list.

    For a less America-biased Top 10, check out Mitch Hawker’s Internet Poll. It uses head-to-head matchups instead of most total votes and it includes a ton of international steel and woodies in its top tens.

    4)Why is Top Thrill Dragster on the list, and not the Kingda ka?
    3) Why is that one trick pony doing on the list:

    The cynical side of me would say that it’s because TTD is more popular b/c it’s at the almighty Cedar Point. Check out my TTD vs. Kingda Ka post for some reader opinions. It may be more than just a CP effect. Top Thrill’s probably the better coaster, but I still don’t think it should be in the top 10 ten coasters in the U.S., much less the world.

    2) Why isn’t Stormrunner on the list?

    I liked Stormrunner, but it just wasn’t long enough to merit a place in my top 10 and I’m not too surprised it’s not in this top 10. It’s fun, but too short.

    1)Why is Montu on the list, and not Alpengeist?

    Your best question of them all. I would assume some prefer Montu over Alpengeist. Simple as that. I put them pretty close, but prefer Alpie’s large, enormous elements and insane speed to Montu’s more compact, closer to the ground layout.

    Thanks for stopping by.

    Reply

Leave a Comment